Skip to main content

“You’re too nice to be a surgeon”

18 Nov 2019 | Emily Hotine Emily Hotine, Athena Swan Coordinator in the Nuffield Department of Surgical Sciences, University of Oxford, explains the impact and biases created by patient perceptions of female surgeons.

Originally published on 8 October 2019. Downloaded from https://www.nds.ox.ac.uk/news/blog/youre-too-nice-to-be-a-surgeon. Protected by copyright.

At a glance, it’s a compliment – after all, who wouldn’t want to be called nice? And it’s most certainly intended as one. It may not initially come across as a gendered phrase – a male surgeon could also surely be deemed uncharacteristically nice in a way that doesn’t seem to fit the stereotypical surgeon mould. However, it’s a phrase that is often heard specifically by female surgeons, and when considered in relation to studies on patient perceptions of female surgeons as warmer and less competent than their male counterparts, we start to see how this idea of ‘niceness’ seems to be linked to gender.

Female surgeons hear many such comments. They report being referred to by patients as, “lady doctor,” being told they, “don’t look like a surgeon,” or being mistaken for a nurse. Taking these stories as a whole, can start to see the biases that have created a perception of surgeons that is inherently masculine, where being a woman is a deviation from the norm. And with 13% of consultant surgeons being female, you have to wonder why surgery remains such a male-dominated field and what has to happen to change that.

But it’s not all negative! In 2016-17, 48% of postgraduate researchers were women (a slight increase of 1% from 2012-13). That’s reassuringly close to gender parity. However, what happens if we compare this figure to the percentage of female undergraduates?  For the same period, 57.5% of students were female. So why are women less likely to continue into research than their male counterparts? And what can we do to bring those barriers down?

 

Surgeon

Of course, the situation for men isn’t perfect either. When it comes to having a family, 40% of men don’t take any paternity leave at all and only 10% take more than two weeks; perhaps more worrying is the fact that those figures are declining. The most commonly cited reason for this is financial. It’s not easy to break free of the patterns many of us live, so is it any wonder that women are still responsible for 65% of the childcare? How do we progress to a point where men and women are able to make decisions regarding parental leave free from the influence of financial pressure?

So how does Athena SWAN fit in? Through the process of applying for a Silver award, the Nuffield Department of Surgical Sciences has already begun to tackle issues around gender inequality. We encourage staff to take advantage of the University’s shared parental leave policy, we’ve worked to support women in their journey through their surgical careers, we’ve offered support with their grant applications, and we’ve worked to increase the visibility of women in the department.

There’s a lot we have to be proud of, and a lot we’ve yet to achieve. It’s taken almost 20 years to increase the number of consultant female surgeons from 3% to 13%, so the journey isn’t likely to be a quick one. We will continue to work to eliminate discrimination in the workplace, to overcome the subtle biases that have led to patients using the term “lady doctor”, and to create a working environment that is flexible so no one has to choose between career and family. It’s work worth undertaking because when we’re successful, we’ll see a stronger department with increased performancegreater innovation, and improved patient care.

Advance HE's Athena SWAN Charter is a framework which is used across the globe to support and transform gender equality within HE and research.

Subject:

Keep up to date - Sign up to Advance HE communications

Our monthly newsletter contains the latest news from Advance HE, updates from around the sector, links to articles sharing knowledge and best practice and information on our services and upcoming events. Don't miss out, sign up to our newsletter now.

Sign up to our enewsletter